Pilot Certification and Qualification Requirements for Air Carrier
Operations
With
the passing of the new Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) rules concerning
airline pilots, the
requirements have been increased significantly. Pilots completing a
Part 141 program like Eastern Michigan University (EMU) with a bachelor's
degree in aviation must have a minimum of 1,000 hours before applying for a
Restricted Airline Transport Pilot (ATP) Certificate to gain a second in
command seat. Students will also be required to obtain 10 hours of
simulator training, six of which must be in a full-motion simulator
meeting 'level C' standards.
There
are few 'entry' level jobs left available to pilots graduating a 141
program. Graduates will be competing for any time building jobs left
available to them; flight instructing, small cargo, and aerial patrol provide
only so many seats. One issue will be graduate stagnation. Without
regional airlines hiring commercial pilots with 250 hours, new pilots will be
competing for jobs to log hours. A second side affect will be a loss in
student enrollments. The new amount of hours required to be logged is
intimidating, and will likely steer prospective students to a different career.
The
new rule is a response to the Colgan Air crash in Buffalo,
New York, a good many factors were involved in that accident, but the FAA
has singled out the relatively low experience the two pilots of that flight had
logged in the accident airframe. In an effort to improve safety and give
first officers more knowledge and experience before flying an air carrier
operation, the FAA is requiring more flight time. Before, a commercial
pilot with 250 hours was a candidate for a first officer position with a
regional carrier. The new rule requires an ATP license, and at least
1,000 hours (if graduated from an approved program). Additionally first
officers must log another 1,000 hours as an airline first officer before flying
as a captain.
The
new Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 61.160, like almost every other
regulation, is aimed at improving safety. Although the FAA is
continuously looking for ways to make flying ever more safe, their hand is
forced by serious aviation accidents to implement a change that will prevent another
occurrence, because to do nothing at all would be far worse. This
regulation will bring new pilots to the airlines with an expanded knowledge
base and more experience, a solid foundation of pilot skills before joining the
airlines, I am confident this will enhance safety. Additionally focus has
been directed to flight captain qualifications and crew resource management skills;
this will undoubtedly create a more efficient cockpit working environment.
Essentially we can expect airline flight crews to come in to the airlines
prepared, skilled, knowledgeable and professionally trained to manage a flight
deck more efficiently than before, able to mitigate hazardous conditions and
ultimately increasing safety.
Although
the recently promulgated regulation is intended for safety there will be a handful of unintended
consequences, and the regional airlines will likely feel it the hardest. The industry’s shortage of qualified pilots
is a complicated issue that will intensify as a result of the new
regulation. The lack of experienced
pilots available for air carrier operations begins with a large number of them
reaching age 65 when they will have to retire.
A reduced budget for militarily trained pilots has limited some great
candidates for the airlines as well. Here
is the pinch: airlines have frequently used regional carriers to recruit pilots
from, and the availability of qualified aviators for these positions will be in
short supply. Training
costs to attain 1,500 hours (or 1,000 hours and bachelor’s degree) is
significantly higher than previously required and will lessen student
enrollment while increasing the time it takes to become an ATP. The issue is further inflamed when
prospective pilots for the regional carriers learn the average starting
salary is around $20,000 a year. Each
of these circumstances combine to illustrate the gravity of the pilot shortage,
and this is hardly a complete list of the industry’s challenges. One solution may be that charter or regional
companies allocate the resources to train pilots to the ATP level. Another possible answer: increase the salary
for professional pilots beginning at regional, charter, or air taxi companies
to attract the needed personnel. These
two options, along with other avenues being explored, have two common traits; encourage
pilots to attain their ATP certificate and incur costs upon regional air
carriers.
References
Bernard,
M. (2012 September/October). Real Learning through Flight Simulation. FAA Safety Briefing. Retrieved from www.faa.gov/news/safety_briefing/
Federal
Aviation Administration. (2013). FAA Boosts Aviation Safety with New Pilot
Qualification Standards [Press release]. Retrieved from http://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?newsId=14838
Goglia,
J. (2013, July 31). What do entry-level regional pilots and McDonald’s workers
have in common? Forbes. Retrieved
from http://www.forbes.com
Maxon,
T. (2013, July 10). Re: FAA will require airline pilots to have at least 1,500
flight hours [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://aviationblog.dallasnews.com/2013/07/15604.html/
National
Transportation Safety Board. (2010). Loss
of Control on Approach Colgan Air, Inc. (NIH Publication No. 10-910401).
Retrieved from http://www.ntsb.gov/doclib/reports/2010/aar1001.pdf
Thurber,
M. (2013, September 1). New training rule to cost upcoming ATPs thousands of
dollars. Aviation International News.
Retrieved from http://www.ainonline.com
I believe you did a very good job at diagnosing the new regulation. I do, however, disagree slightly that this will inherently increase safety. We have a mentality in aviation that more hours equate to more knowledge, and that is not necessarily the case. It depends on where a pilot receives those hours. For example, if a pilot builds 1000 hours by crop dusting, and leaves the same airport every morning and goes over the same acreage of crops buzzing them and then lands back at his home airport, what experience might he really gain in interacting with ATC? What about sharing responsibility with a PIC? Sometimes familiarity can cause pilots to become too complacent.
ReplyDeleteI believe this legislation is a knee-jerk reaction to appease the public; to say "we are training our pilots better!" and allow the general public to feel safer. The general public is not always aware of how many safety implementations aviation does indeed have, and I think this legislation also has the potential to create pilots who may even have formed bad habits in the process of their 1000/1500 hour building.
Of course, this is all speculation on my part. "Pilot shortages" has been a rumor that comes and go all the time and, depending on who you talk to determines if there really is going to be a pilot shortage. It logically seems there would be, but we can only speculate on the pilot shortage, not guarantee it. The same principal can pay to FAR 61.160. It may appear officially that it is going to increase safety, but whether is actually does or not is all speculation.
I do like the area of the pilot shortage that I did not give much thought to. With the new regulation taking place with much higher minimums this just adds to the decrease of available pilots for now and in the future. This only adds to just some of the other reasons you stated with a shrinking supply of qualified pilots. There are many other factors outside of this regulation that are or could have effect on the amount of available pilots in the long run. However, this regulation could have a critical outcome for possible future pilots adding to the high price of training and over whelming outlook for achieving there goals.
ReplyDeleteWhile I agree with the majority of your post, I would have to say that while the pilots may be more experienced when entering into the airlines, that doesn't necessarily make them safer pilots. Much like Time Lord said above, it really all depends on the type of experience that these pilots are gaining while building their time. I also agree that starting salaries may need to be significantly increase by the regional airlines if flight schools are going to be able to continue bringing in new pilots. This was a good issue to bring up that I never had thought about until now.
ReplyDeleteI like that fact that you brought up about prospective students. I also agree that when they ask how long it will be till they get into the airlines and someone says 1000 hours, they will look at that as a huge barrier to overcome and probably look to another career. This is especially true when you pile on the fact that a first officer slot will only pay a $25,000 salary to start out at, they will definitely become discouraged.
ReplyDelete